24 June, 2009
AFP By Marianne Barriaux
BEIJING (AFP) ¡X Leading Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo has been formally arrested
for subversion, state media reported, six months after he was detained in the
wake of signing a pro-democracy charter.
Liu was arrested on Tuesday for "alleged agitation activities aimed at
subversion of the government and overthrowing of the socialist system," Xinhua
news agency said, citing Beijing police.
The 53-year-old writer, who was involved in the 1989 Tiananmen pro-democracy
protests, has been held incommunicado since December after signing Charter 08, a
widely circulated petition that called for greater democracy in China.
"Liu has been engaged in agitation activities, such as spreading of rumours and
defaming of the government, aimed at subversion of the state and overthrowing
the socialism system in recent years," Xinhua quoted a police statement as
Liu has confessed to the charge, the statement added.
His lawyer, Mo Shaoping, told AFP he had no knowledge of the arrest. Mo has not
been allowed to see Liu since December.
Beijing police declined to comment when contacted by AFP.
The arrest comes amid a wider crackdown on dissent as China marks a series of
sensitive political anniversaries this year, with dissidents complaining of
harassment and tighter Internet controls.
China earlier this month passed the 20th anniversary of the crackdown on the
1989 Tiananmen Square protests with stifling security and next faces October's
60th anniversary of the founding of communist China.
Liu has been under a form of house arrest in an undisclosed location away from
his home since December, with rights groups calling for Beijing to release him
and make public any charges against him.
Nicholas Bequelin, a Hong Kong-based researcher with Human Rights Watch, said
the arrest meant Liu would almost certainly go to prison.
"The legal proceedings are irrelevant. They are only an assembly line to a
predetermined result," he told AFP.
"We believe that Liu Xiaobo has done nothing but exercise his right to freedom
of expression and in no circumstances should he have been arrested."
Amnesty International also condemned Liu's arrest.
"This use of state security charges to punish activists for merely expressing
their views must stop," it said in an emailed statement.
Bequelin said Chinese authorities had basically tolerated Liu's dissident
writings and other activities in recent years.
But he said Liu's arrest made clear that hardline elements in the government
blamed for a tightening of political controls since before last year's Beijing
Olympics had gained the upper hand.
"The Ministry of Public Security has seen its power considerably enhanced and
they are more aggressive. The room for dissent is shrinking," he said.
Liu, who was jailed for nearly two years for his role in the 1989 Tiananmen
protests and then again in the mid-1990s, headed a writer's group called the
Independent Chinese PEN Centre when police took him away.
His case has drawn intense international criticism, with both the European Union
and the United States demanding his quick release.
Novelists such as Britain's Salman Rushdie and Italy's Umberto Eco, as well as
Nobel laureates in literature including Irish poet Seamus Heaney, have also
campaigned for Liu's release.
June 26, 2009
Wall Street Journal Asia BY EVA PILS
The party-state has yet to understand the full power of the ideas it is so
anxious to suppress.
Official Chinese media announced Wednesday that Liu Xiaobo, one of China's most
prominent intellectuals, had been formally arrested on suspicion of "inciting
subversion of state power" following a six-month detention. The eventual
decision to arrest and charge him does not come as a surprise: It only confirms
that the Chinese leadership is becoming more paranoid in its handling of dissent
at a time of intensifying social, political and moral crisis.
Mr. Liu first became famous for his activism during the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989, but his recent arrest reveals a lot about the state of political change in China today. Based on the facts publicly available, Mr. Liu's only "crime" appears to be that he exercised his constitutional right to free speech in a political system still unable genuinely to tolerate dissent.
Mr. Liu was a co-author of Charter 08, a clear, bold and persuasively worded
call for political and legal liberalization, and he was detained just two days
before the document's release last December. The "subversion" crime with which
he has now been charged makes a mockery of the civil rights -- including freedom
of speech -- that the Chinese Constitution professes to safeguard. These rights
often contradict the principles of Party Rule and lack effective protection in
In 2004, a commitment to protecting human rights was written into the Chinese
Constitution. At that time some still hoped China might be on the way to a more
liberal system through gradual, top-down legal reforms. But in the following
years, the prospects of further liberalization of the system closed down. It was
as though the party-state had come to realize how untenable its current hold on
power would be under genuine rule of law. As cases of rights violations and
government corruption accumulated in the midst of economic boom, the leadership
decided to change its approach to these problems, from better protecting citizen
rights to more comprehensive authoritarian repression. Courts have been reminded
that they must serve "the Party's cause" and "social stability." Human-rights
lawyers have been obstructed, harassed, subjected to cruelty and disbarred.
Petitioners have been beaten, detained and even put in psychiatric institutions.
Yet the voices of dissatisfied citizens have grown stronger and louder: The
Internet is burgeoning with citizen-journalists uncovering new cases of
corruption and official venality. More streets and fields have become scenes of
labor and land-rights protests as more citizens have taken the freedom at least
to demand justice.
It was a sense of growing crisis, of "now or never," that led to the production
of Charter 08, which was modeled on the Czechoslovakian Charter 77. "This is a
historic moment for China," the drafters wrote. "The decline of the existing
system has reached the point where change is no longer optional." Charter 08
appealed to many citizens. One of the thousands of Chinese signers,
understanding full well that she could face severe consequences, wrote that she
signed it "after a good cry."
By formally arresting Mr. Liu, the authorities have set another sign of
assertive return to an authoritarian political model that emphasizes Chinese
characteristics and leaves no room for "universal values." Mr. Liu is almost
certain to join the ranks of dissidents previously convicted of "inciting
subversion," among them, the disappeared human-rights lawyer Gao Zhisheng and
the imprisoned activist Hu Jia. What could now save Mr. Liu from an unjust
conviction and prison sentence would be a political, not a judicial, decision.
But the party-state has yet to understand the full power of the ideas it is so
anxious to suppress.
Ms. Pils is assistant professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong Faculty of Law.